Growth Strategies
Whitwell & Co. manages six distinct investment strategies: Moderate Growth, Total Growth, Large Cap Quant Growth, Small Cap Quant Growth, American Value, and Downside Protected Equity Growth. Each is designed for different goals, risk tolerances, and time horizons.
Different goals often live in different accounts. A client might have one bucket dedicated to long-term growth, another reserved for shorter-term needs, and a third earmarked for a specific objective. When that is the case, we assign each strategy at the account or bucket level, matching it to the objective that account is meant to serve. Clients with multiple objectives often run several of our strategies side by side, each one chosen because it fits the goal of the account it sits in.
Moderate Growth Strategy
Objective: to pursue long-term returns comparable to the S&P 500 while seeking to reduce downside risk. Implementation: liquid ETFs across all asset classes but only seven (7) at one time. Daily liquidity. Key risk is stock market risk; returns depend on how various assets in the strategy interact with prevailing market conditions. Invests in more than just equities: rates, credit, commodities, metals, and international. Seeks positive returns regardless of market direction via an "all asset" and "risk on / risk off" approach and being an actively managed strategy, it is rebalanced monthly. Requires a minimum five year holding period.
Total Growth Strategy
Objective: to pursue long-term growth, seeking returns above those of the S&P 500 over the holding period, net of fees, while aiming to keep downside risk at or below that of the S&P 500. There is no assurance these objectives will be achieved. Implementation: 10 stocks that are rebalanced four or more times a year. Recommended horizon is ten years; liquidity is daily. Risk is materially similar to the S&P 500 but the goal is a substantially lower ulcer index than the S&P 500.
Large Cap Quant Growth Strategy
Objective: to pursue aggressive long-term growth, seeking returns above those of the S&P 500 over holding periods not less than ten years. This strategy can be characterized as aggressive growth and can be expected to experience greater and longer drawdowns than the Whitwell Total Growth Strategy. Implementation: 10 large-cap stocks. Rebalanced no less than once a year.
Small Cap Quant Growth Strategy
Objective: to pursue returns above those of the S&P 500. More aggressive than the Large Cap Quant Growth Strategy. This is a strategy for clients who can endure substantial price fluctuation in pursuit of long-term growth. This strategy is comprised of ten small-cap stocks that are trading at comparatively low valuations and requires a minimum ten year holding period. This strategy reconstitutes every February, May, August and November.
American Value Strategy
Objective: algorithmic stock investment strategy designed to pursue returns above those of the S&P 500 over a minimum time horizon of five years and to help protect capital by purchasing shares in companies at relatively low valuations (hence the term "value") and even then, only selecting from the companies that rank highest in terms of profitability. The strategy is based on principles of value investing popularized by Benjamin Graham and Warren Buffett, and specifically the idea of buying profitable companies at a discount to their intrinsic value and cash flow. This strategy is comprised of twenty-five (25) small-cap stocks and is reconstituted no less than once a year.
Downside Protected Equity Growth Strategy
This is a non-traditional strategy that seeks exposure to the S&P 500 with a defined level of downside protection, in exchange for giving up some of the upside. Like any strategy it carries risks, including caps on upside, the terms and creditworthiness of the underlying instruments, and the possibility of loss.
In a sense, it is similar to the return profile of a fixed-index annuity or life insurance investment account. This strategy has three primary benefits. First, it allows clients to get exposure to the U.S. stock market. Second, it seeks to limit downside risk over the holding period. Third, it is a liquid strategy. Minimum recommended holding period is one calendar year.
Which Strategy Fits Your Needs?
The right strategy depends on your time horizon, income needs, tax situation, and comfort with volatility. Schedule a call to discuss which approach aligns with your goals.
Who This Is For
- Long-term investors who can commit to each strategy's minimum holding period, from five to ten years
- Clients who want disciplined, risk-managed growth rather than chasing the hottest asset
- Investors comfortable matching a specific strategy to a specific goal or account
- Those who can tolerate meaningful drawdowns in pursuit of long-term returns
- Short-term traders, or anyone who needs the money within a few years
- Investors who cannot tolerate drawdowns in the range of 35% to 50% (these are equity-market realities, not a function of how we invest. In the dot-com crash the Nasdaq 100 fell roughly -83% into its October 2002 low, and the S&P 500 fell roughly -49%; the S&P 500's deepest modern decline, about -57%, came in the 2007 to 2009 financial crisis. We aim to reduce drawdowns, not to eliminate the risk of equity markets.)
- Anyone seeking guaranteed returns or a promise of beating the market
Risks, Costs, and What to Weigh
- These are growth strategies; you should not invest unless you can tolerate maximum drawdowns in the range of 35% to 50%.
- Each strategy carries a minimum holding period, from one year to ten years; selling early defeats the strategy's design.
- Back-tested history illustrates how a strategy would have performed; it is not a promise of future results, and no specific return is guaranteed.
- Different strategies suit different goals; the right choice depends on your time horizon, income needs, tax situation, and tolerance for volatility.
The Six Growth Strategies at a Glance
Whitwell & Co.'s six growth strategies at a glance.
| Strategy | Objective | How it is built | Min. holding period | Risk orientation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Moderate Growth | Seeks to match long-term S&P 500 returns with less downside risk | 7 liquid ETFs across all asset classes, rebalanced monthly | 5 years | Lower volatility, all-asset |
| Total Growth | Seeks returns above the S&P 500 net of fees, with downside no greater than the S&P 500 | 10 stocks, rebalanced 4+ times a year | 10 years | Equity-like, aims for a lower ulcer index |
| Large Cap Quant Growth | Seeks returns above the S&P 500 over 10+ years | 10 large-cap stocks, rebalanced at least yearly | 10 years | Aggressive growth, deeper drawdowns |
| Small Cap Quant Growth | Seeks returns above the S&P 500 | 10 small-cap stocks at low valuations, reconstituted quarterly | 10 years | Most aggressive, large price swings |
| American Value | Seeks returns above the S&P 500 using value screens | 25 small-cap stocks bought at low valuations | 5 years | Value-oriented |
| Downside Protected Equity Growth | Seeks S&P 500 exposure with downside protection, in exchange for capped upside | A monthly ladder of index-linked ETFs, one added each month, each on an annual reset | 1 year | Capital-protection focus, capped upside |
Each entry is a stated objective, not a guarantee; all investing involves risk of loss and there is no assurance any objective will be met.
Written by: Stefan Whitwell, CFA®, CIPM
Reviewed by: Rosemary Wright, CFP®
Last updated:
Sources (verified):
- S&P Dow Jones Indices, S&P 500 historical index levels
- Nasdaq, Nasdaq 100 historical index levels